Delivering Revenue From Product Reviews

What’s the point of product reviews? Links? Branding? Building trust? Ultimately, revenue. Every piece of SEO should be related back to increasing revenues for a website. Let’s look at two cases of product reviews that can and should be implemented that abide by the updated laws of Google.

Google more recently added exchanging goods or services for a link. It also includes sending someone a free product in return for a link.

Link_Schemes(Google Webmaster Tools:

The main reason many SEOs do reviews is for…..links. They have quotas to fill & demands from managers/clients. Exact match & varying the anchor text around your main keyword can still work as of September 2013, but for how long?

Some reviews drive a little revenue. But eh, by using Rafflecoptor you can help reviews + giveaway to drive up social numbers which may or may not have a determined value to the business.

Let’s stop worrying about followed links with anchor text. Let’s stop looking at inflating social numbers as a false positive of success. Here are the examples. We haven’t tested the second one, so have at it.

SEER did a giveaway well over a year ago with a client who sent a pair of shoes & paid for a review on a fashion site. It didn’t matter that the links were followed or nofollowed, the real story was that the shoes were a sought-after item and people wanted them. Bad.

OMG shoes
(Lots of other funny ones at

We found a product we knew would draw interest. Not an iTunes card interest, but the type of interest a $400 pair of women’s shoes would draw when promoted on a site all about women’s fashion.

To enter, we didn’t want Facebook or Twitter followers, we wanted that audience to come to our site & have an experience. We wanted that audience to see the high quality shots of these sought after products and create an excitement about our client & our giveaway.

1. Visit the site.
2. Find a pair of shoes you love.
3. Enter by leaving a comment about that pair of shoes on the contest site.
4. Hold breath until winner is announced.

Connecting with the right audience produced the following results:

Comments: 500
Visits: 1700
Pageviews: 12/visit (50% above site avg)
Facebook shares: minimum
Twitter shares: minimum
Pins: 100+
Revenue: $3000+

Provide a sought-after product to a related site with an interested audience and you get some decent metrics.

$3000+ in revenue made us back the cost of the product and to get it on the site. Success! But we also had 125/500 comments come from people with websites. Mainly fashion websites. And we knew exactly what they wanted. This is the opportunity to form new relationships with more shoes.

The second example of a giveaway that increases revenue that I have not tested yet, but why not share it? If someone wants to comment with this type of a test below, I’ll gladly update the post to link to it.

This works if:
1. Your company has a price match guarantee.
2. You have low prices.
3. You sell a product that people need & they need often. If you sell sell vitamins, contact lenses, salon/beauty products, office supplies, etc., then I think this is worth a test.

Step 1: Find a site that has an audience that uses your product

I would look to disqualify sites that post multiple times each day and/or have minimal interaction with their existing posts. You need an active audience. I would also avoid bloggers who label themselves as high maintenance; it’s usually true.

Step 2: Set up a review of your product or company

This will require pitching a few sites. Be a real person, show that you’re a great brand, offer a worthwhile incentive to the site & if you can’t think of a good one, ask them what their readers would respond to best. One thing to note: if you have poor customer service then this probably won’t work well for you.

Step 3: Define how to enter

This is the most important part (I bet you’re thinking “it better be, the first two steps are old news.) To enter, have people go to your site & comment how much money they would save buying from you vs their current retailer. If you have a lowest price guarantee, the comments will bring a realization to everyone who enters that they will either save money through your current prices OR spend the same amount they are now with potentially better customer service.

Comments turn into calls to action that put the potential converting visitors into the shoes of already owning the product.


Lets say you’re one of the thousands of animal shelters out there. Hold a contest with an audience that would be open to adoption. To enter:

  1. Visit the animals page.
  2. Select a dog or cat that reminds you of an old family pet or friend’s pet.
  3. Write in a story about a great memory you had with that animal.

This obviously appeals to the emotional side of the visitor. It’s not just blindly “follow us on Twitter, like us on Facebook.”

SEO reviews without followed links aren’t about SEO at all, they’re about defining the ROI of the review/contest.

If you’re looking for more to read up on, visit for case studies and details about other strategies.